Handmade Pasta.

Seasonal Plates.

Crafted Cocktails.

Lunch, Brunch + Dinner Year-Round

Lasagne made with fresh pasta, San Marzano tomato sugo, fresh mozzarella, parmesan and our house made focaccia. Maker Cafe, Martha's Vineyard
Blueberry pancakes, elderflower lemon curd, strawberry rhubarb compote. Saturday Brunch at Maker Cafe, Martha's Vineyard
Fresh tagliatelle pasta with mushrooms, herbs, and grated Parmesan on a fork. Made in house Maker Cafe, Martha's Vineyard
Seared scallops garnished with microgreens and served in a light butter sauce on white plates Maker Cafe, Martha's Vineyard, catering events and weddings
Close-up of a grilled chicken tomato focaccia sandwich. lunch at Maker Cafe, Martha's Vineyard
Three colorful cocktails with ice and citrus garnishes on a bar counter. best cocktails Maker Cafe, Martha's Vineyard
Hands arranging freshly made yellow pasta noodles on a work surface. fresh pasta, fresh pasta shop Maker Cafe, Martha's Vineyard
White plastic colander filled with uncooked shell-shaped pasta. fresh pasta, fresh pasta shop Maker Cafe, Martha's Vineyard
Restaurant table with a tall glass of white wine, mixed green salad, utensils, and menu. brunch Maker Cafe, Martha's Vineyard
Close-up of creamy shell pasta with breadcrumbs and parsley, served with toasted seeded bread and a green salad. pasta made on marthas vineyard. fresh pasta. Maker Cafe, Martha's Vineyard
Seared fish fillet with roasted vegetables, green purée, brown sauce, and shaved onion on a white plate
Grilled chicken sandwich with tomato, lettuce, and sauce served with creamy orange soup topped with herbs, seeds, and crispy strips. lunch specials, soup + sandwich, pasta + salad, soup + salad Maker Cafe, Martha's Vineyard

THIS WEEK AT MAKER CAFÉ

JOIN US FOR SPECIALS OCTOBER-APRIL

Lunch Specials

Monday-Friday 11am-2:30pm

Maker Duo

Choice of Pasta+Salad or Sandwich+Soup - $22

Pasta Choices: Alfredo, Marina, Pesto or Mac+Cheese with Caesar or Mixed Greens

Sandwich Choices: Mushroom Melt, Chicken Tomato Focaccia, BLT or Grilled Cheese with Soup of the Day

Available for Dine In or Take Out

———————————————————————

Join Us from 5pm-9pm for these Winter Specials

Regular Menu Always Available

Dine In Only

AT THE BAR

½ PRICE PASTAS

Every Night, 5pm-6:30pm

choose any pasta from our menu

TUESDAYS

$20 Pasta Night

Select Pastas

WEDNESDAYS

Caesar Salad, Crispy Truffled Potatoes

+ Martini - $30 per person

Don’t worry, Girl Dinner is for Everyone

MOCKTAILS AVAILABLE

THURSDAYS

3 courses for $50 per person

Menu changes weekly

Regular Menu Always Available

SATURDAYS

BRUNCH 10am-2pm

Maker Cafe Winter Nights promotional menu featuring Tuesday pasta, Wednesday girl dinner, Thursday prix fixe, half-price bar pastas, lunch specials, and Saturday brunch. winter nights on marthas vineyard Maker Cafe, Martha's Vineyard speciality night

Meet the Makers

Chef Carlos & Sheenagh

Smiling couple embracing indoors, with a woman hugging a bearded man from behind. Sheenagh Caridi and Chef Carlos Montoya. Martha's Vineyard Restauranteurs
Two chefs serving appetizers outdoors, with one holding a wooden platter and the other carrying a tray of plated bites. sheenagh caridi and chef carlos montoya. wedding and event caterers.
Smiling man in a pasta café T-shirt and woman in a blue-and-white striped dress standing in a cozy restaurant.

“Pasta is a vessel to showcase beautiful local ingredients” -Chef Carlos

At the heart of our restaurant is a passion for crafting exceptional, homemade pasta that celebrates the art of local cuisine. Chef Carlos Montoya, our talented culinary creator, brings years of experience and a deep love for fresh, handcrafted ingredients to every dish. From perfectly rolled pastas to flavorful sauces, Chef Carlos’ approach is rooted in tradition, yet always with a modern twist.

Alongside him, Sheenagh Caridi, co-owner and General Manager, ensures every guest experience is seamless from our fresh pasta and sauces sold by the pound, or dining inside our cafe, to our intimate in-home dining experiences, catering services, and unforgettable wedding events. Sheenagh's extensive background in hospitality allows her to bring a personalized touch to every event, creating not just a meal, but a memorable experience.

Together, Chef Carlos and Sheenagh blend their talents and passions to bring you the best in casual fine dining comfort food, made with love and served with care. Whether you’re grabbing a pound of fresh pasta to cook at home or enjoying a multi-course meal at one of our events, you can always expect quality, authenticity, and a taste of the Island in every bite.